Abdul's paper
1st iteration for open review The reviewers advised a further iteration is needed for all the publishing criteria to be met.
The reviewers have given indications of what Abdul needs to attend in the comments added to the paper, which can be accessed here — Joy's review of 1st iteration and Javier's review of 1st iteration.
Note to Abdul — Both reviewers are recommending that if you attend to what they have indicated in the 'comments' they have added to your paper then, in their opinion, it will meet all publishing criteria. Please look them through and hold the publishing criteria in mind as you review your paper to decide on what amendments to make to your paper.
To contribute to this conversation please contact us.